About Critical Mass [dot] Writing [dot] Reviews [dot] Contact
« previous entry | return home | next entry »

December 11, 2002 [feather]
Boalt's Bob Greene

Jack at Captain Yips sends an email comparing the situation of soon-to-be-ex-Boalt Dean John Dwyer to ex-Chicago Tribune columnist Bob Greene:


There is another way of looking at this that complements the bucket of dead fish smell. Aside from the agenda of the former student and her attorney, there is the school's agenda. This situation is very similar to the dismissal of Bob Greene from The Chicago Tribune earlier this year. ... Greene had been a prominent columnist for the Trib for a long time. Rather a boring one, in a lot of opinions including mine, but he had his audience. Earlier this year he was dismissed nominally for a "improper" relationship with a girl about whom he had written a story. The story and the "relationship" occurred years ago. Recently, she contacted Greene and he seems to have pulled some strings to drive her away. This part of the story is very vague-he may or may not have used a contact at the FBI or he may have had someone pretend to be an FBI agent. No one is talking. The young woman then emailed the editor of the Trib, who pulled the ripcord on Greene. Created a big splash in journalism circles. ... What is interesting and similar is that Greene seems to have womanized industriously for years, and notoriously so within the profession. That Trib management knew about his behavior is beyond doubt. I think that he had become an embarrassment to the organization years ago, and the management took this opportunity to dump him. In the Boalt case, I suspect that the Dean had outworn his welcome, and this accusation was a handy way to expel the unwanted element. Neither Greene nor the Dean (couldn't resist that) did anything they hadn't been doing for years and years and years; in both cases, I think institutional elements had long ago sharpened their knives for them, and were all too happy to take advantage of the accusations. And both men had so much baggage that they couldn't resist.

And Boalt, like the Trib, welcomed the opportunity to cast a political maneuver as a ritual communal cleansing. Neil Sternberg described the Tribune in terms that could as well be applied to Boalt: "Perhaps the most amazing thing about this entire episode is how quickly the Tribune cast its premiere columnist's being fired for using the newspaper as a chick magnet into a moral triumph. The newspaper positively glowed with pride, in a flurry of self-administered back-pats." At Boalt, as at the Tribune, accusations of sexual misconduct have turned a question of political expediency into one of moral necessity. Feminist students and faculty at Boalt have protested Dwyer's deanship as a sexist regime since he got the job two years ago. Now they not only have their "proof," but they have a situation that conveniently reframes ideological differences as ethical ones: it is no longer a question of whether Dwyer's managerial style excludes women, but one of what can be done to prevent similar predators from terrorizing women students in the future. Key word: conveniently.

UPDATE: A reader disagrees with the analogy between Dwyer and Greene:


...the post analogizing this case to the Greene case is way off. The irony of this case is that Dean Dwyer was doing a lot of good for Boalt. His mission was to take Boalt from a top-ten law school to one of the top two or three. He had increased minority and women enrollment even compared to the last year before Prop 209 outlawed race- and gender-based admissions policies. He spent a lot of time raising money for the school to great success. He could be found most nights and weekends working late at the law school and then back again early in the morning.

Touche: the analogy is a bad one if we see it as a comparison of Dwyer and Greene as professionals. But: it is an excellent one if we see it as a comparison of Berkeley and the Chicago Tribune as institutions. That one man was enormously effective in his job and the other was, according to some, past his prime merely underscores the indiscriminately ritualized nature of the institutional script the school and the paper each followed when the accusational shoe dropped.

posted on December 11, 2002 10:55 AM