About Critical Mass [dot] Writing [dot] Reviews [dot] Contact
« previous entry | return home | next entry »

February 17, 2008 [feather]
Cutting class

It's always interesting to see when faculty members decide to suspend regular teaching operations, either canceling class because of some compelling conflicting event or devoting class time to discussion of material far afield from the syllabus or subject of the course. It's also always intriguing to notice when deans lead the way.

Here's an email sent to the William & Mary faculty by Dean Carl Strikwerda, in the wake of the Board of Visitors' decision not to renew President Nichol's contract:


----- Original Message -----
From: "Carl Strikwerda"
To:
Sent: Tuesday, February 12, 2008 5:34 PM
Subject: [fas-d] Classes in Arts & Sciences on Wednesday and Thursday

Dear Colleagues:

I know that the news we received this morning from President Nichol about his decision to resign was deeply saddening for many of you, as it was for me. President Nichol was a passionate advocate for the values of liberal arts education, diversity, and free inquiry. I respected him as a leader and as a friend. I will miss him greatly. I would be dishonest if I did not also say that I am also very concerned about the future of William and Mary. In this difficult time, and in the months ahead, all of us will need to re-dedicate ourselves to the values that we hold dear in order that William and Mary continues to be the vibrant educational institution and strong campus community that it is.

I can also say that I am committed to doing whatever I can to help Provost Feiss, Interim President Taylor Reveley, and Rector Powell maintain our strengths as a college and an intellectual community.

A number of faculty members have indicated that they plan to not meet classes on Wednesday and Thursday in protest of the decision of the Board of Visitors. This is a difficult time for students and faculty. All of us have to deal with our emotions and our need to share our opinions in the way that we judge best. As it happens, I will be meeting with my students in my class tomorrow morning, but neither I nor my co-instructor will lecture. We will explain the situation on campus to the our students and ask them to share their thoughts, feelings, and questions. I trust that each of you will make the appropriate decision for yourself about whether or not to hold regular classes or allow your students to discuss the situation with you and their classmates.

I realize that the situation on campus may continue to raise questions, some of them troubling ones, for you and your students or some time. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have concerns that you wish to share. More than ever, I appreciate all the good work that you do as teachers, scholars, scientists, artists, and academic leaders. Together with our excellent students, you make the College of William and Mary a community of which I am still proud to be a part.

Best,
Carl J. Strikwerda
Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences
College of William and Mary
P.O. 8795
Williamsburg, VA 23187-8795
Phone 757-221-2470
Fax 757-221-2464
cstrik@wm.edu
Campus Location: 134 Ewell Hall
Jamestown Road


The Board of Visitors' decision, and Nichol's subsequent resignation, followers of this story will know, have sparked a great deal of controversy both within the William & Mary community and beyond. What I'd like to do here is just open the thread up to readers for comment.

What do you make of Dean Strikwerda's decision to send this email to the faculty? What are we to make of his decision to devote his own class time to the therapeutic endeavor of helping students express their thoughts and feelings about the change in College leadership? What about his tacit endorsement of those faculty members who decided to cancel classes on two consecutive days so that they could register a protest to the Board?

Comments are open.

posted on February 17, 2008 10:59 AM




Trackback Pings:

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.erinoconnor.org/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/1401






Comments:

If nothing else, this is a silly emotional response to the situation at W&M. I mean, nobody died or anything; there's simply going to be a shakeup in the bureaucracy. Question: how many other professions are there where people can skip work on the public (or customer's) dime in the name of some cause or because their feelings are hurt?

Posted by: TomG at February 17, 2008 12:34 PM



Disgraceful. Cancelling classes -- and thereby forcing students to spend their hard-earned tuition money on some sort of non-academic bull session designed and parameterized by the Dean, as well as implicitly encouraging other faculty to follow suit -- is the polar opposite of what it means to be a professional in the field of higher ed. The Dean, of all people, ought to have a grasp on the importance of study, and especially the importance of staying on the job during times of upheaval. Instead, the Dean is saying that feeling good is more important than being devoted to one's studies.

I mean, could he not hold an evening session to do this stuff, with free pizza or something to attract students?

Posted by: Robert Talbert at February 18, 2008 3:21 AM



The professor's email seems to be a case of presumptive arrogance masquerading as compassion. If the Vice Chancellor at my university were to resign I hardly expect my students would care to spend as much as five minutes in class discussing it - much less 50 or, God help us, 75 minutes. While the issue surely matters to the professor why does he think his students will feel the same? They likely had very little knowledge of, and even less direct contact with, Nichol, and few of them are likely to take more than a passing interest in the resignation.

I'm frankly surprised and disappointed the professor can afford to lose an entire class on this issue. It makes me wonder a little about his syllabus.

Posted by: D. Wells at February 18, 2008 8:09 AM



If this was W&M Inc. manufacturers of widgets, instead of the College of W&M and the Board of Directors fired the CEO would the lower level managers not come to work in protest and said managers tell their workers not to come to work. I don't think so---those profs need to get a grip!

Posted by: Bill at February 18, 2008 5:10 PM



Cutting class and splitting infinitives... for shame.

Posted by: luke at February 21, 2008 11:32 AM





Post a comment:




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)